Pick up an IN-SEASON RECIPE and lots of yummy info on your #local #food supply. bit.ly/1QS1Ldx

Agri in die media

SA state trying to cover up land reform failures

The Citizen
10 September 2017

Despite R2bn spent annually, redistribution efforts may in fact be making people in rural areas even poorer.
According to a report in Afrikaans weekly Rapport, the new approach to the controversial project of land reform in South Africa has been failing, and government is so concerned about new research findings that it allegedly tried to prevent the researchers from continuing with their work.
In a front-page article dealing with the work of the Institute for Poverty, Land and Agrarian Studies (Plaas), it was alleged that the expensive land reform programme has been resulting in farm workers losing their jobs and even their rights to accommodation.
The state’s programme of acquiring land for redistribution is allegedly also contributing in other ways to the increase of poverty in rural areas.
Plaas and international researchers have been doing the research for the Western Cape government and their findings have hitherto not been published. Rapport alleges that the “government was so upset about the damning findings that researchers were in the interim denied access to more farms and state data”.
As a result, researchers from the University of Toronto in Canada decided to make their findings public.
More than R2 billion is invested by government each year into land reform and redistribution. Since 2011, the land has remained state-owned and is redistributed through hire arrangements, but this approach appears to be creating problems
The first round of research looked at 11 farms in Nelson Mandela Bay in the Eastern Cape. On three of the farms, workers were allegedly left without refuge.
On another farm, people who had been living on the land for generations were being made to pay hire to the state and had lost their income as labourers.
On another livestock farm, long-term contracts had still not been established despite three families being established on the land.
On at least one state-owned chicory farm being partly run by the University of Fort Hare – as well as several others – workers were being paid less than minimum wage.
Researcher Dr Ruth Hall was quoted as saying that although good intentions were being shown, the state would have to improve its capacity to manage land if it wished to continue with its current approach. She said that the rhetoric of “radical land reform” was being chanted while the state did not have the ability to administer agricultural land.
“This land reform is being done for people other than the poor,” she was quoted as saying.
“Each of these problems can be solved.” She charged that proper accountability and oversight were not being ensured to ensure effectiveness.
The department of rural development declined to comment to Rapport.

Posted on October 9, 2017 in Uncategorized


Agri Wes-Kaap lede log in

Nog nie 'n Agri Wes-Kaap lid?

Agri Wes-Kaap:

  • fokus voortdurend op die ontwikkeling van vooruitstrewende landboustrategieë.
  • bewerkstellig 'n positiewe beleidsraamwerk vir die landbou in die Wes-Kaap waarbinne wette, regulasies, ordinansies en gesindhede landbou-vriendelik is.
  • sien toe dat landbou in die Wes-Kaap sy eie toekoms verseker, deur aktiewe betrokkenheid op alle lewensterreine.
  • skep ‘n kollektiewe magsbasis vir die landbougemeenskap in die Wes-Kaap.
  • bied ‘n fokuspunt waardeur die kollektiewe belang van landbou in die Wes-Kaap optimaal bevorder word.

Doen aansoek om ‘n Agri Wes-Kaap lid te word Ons sal reëlings met jou plaaslike Landbouvereniging tref en skakel jou terug.

Not an Agri member yet?

Agri Western Cape:

  • constantly focuses on developing more progressive agricultural strategies.
  • negotiates a positive policy framework on behalf of agriculture in the Western Cape, within which laws, regulations, ordinances and attitudes are agriculture friendly.
  • provides a platform for agriculture in the Western Cape to ensure its own future, through involvement in all spheres of life.
  • creates a collective power base for the agricultural community of the Western Cape.
  • optimally promotes the collective interest of agriculture in the Western Cape.

Apply for Agri WC membership We will make arrangements via your local Agricultural Association and get back to you.


I-Agri Western Cape:

  • ihlala igxile kuphuhliso lwamaqhinga ezolimo anenkqubela nangakumbi.
  • yenza uthethathethwano loyilo lwemigaqo-nkqubo emihle egameni lwezolimo eNtshona Koloni, ekuye kuthi kuyo yuqunlunqwe imithetho, imigaqo, izibhengezo kunye nendlela yokucinga evelana nezolimo.
  • idala iqonga lokuba ezolimo ziqinisekisa ikamva lazo, ngokuzibandakanya kwiinkalo zonke zobomi.
  • idala isiseko esinamandla kuluntu lwezolimo eNtshona Koloni.
  • ikhuthaza ngokwaneleyo umdla kuwonke-wonke kwezolimo eNtshona Koloni.

Yenza isicelo sokuba lilingu Siza kwenza amalungiselelo neManyano yeZolimo yengingqi yakho, size sibuyele kuwe.

Subscribe to our fun,
educational, inspiring
and winning updates -
and Grow Greatness
in your home.